
Full
Spectrum™ Mushroom
Mycelium Products |
Beta-Glucan
Type Immune Enhancers - A Comparison
Comparison
of IMMUNE-ASSIST,
AHCC, MGN-3, Lentinan, PSK, PSP, Coriolan
and Maitake D-Fraction
[with a note on Yeast Beta Glucan]
We are
contacted almost daily with questions about how IMMUNE-ASSIST compares
to the other widely used mushroom polysaccharide medications. "what
is so much better about Immune-Assist" is the question we are
usually asked. Here we will try to address that question from a scientific
perspective.
The therapeutic
compound found in most mushrooms, which has stimulatory effect on
the Immune System is a class of compounds known as polysaccharide.
The term polysaccharide means "multiple sugar". The term
sugar in this case is not what you normally think of to put in your
coffee, but rather refers to the simple sugars which are the main
building block of life. The most common organic substance in the world
(in the universe?) is a polysaccharide. It is called Cellulose. This
is the cell wall material of all plants. To a Scientist this compound
has a more complex name, 1-4 Beta Glucan.
DEFINE
BETA GLUCAN: Glucose molecules that are joined together with Beta
(vs. Alpha) bonds. In the case of Cellulose, the bonds link from the
#1 carbon on the first glucose molecule to the #4 carbon on the next
molecule. (1-4 beta glucan)
As most
sugars have 6 carbons, there are many possible ways to connect the
sugars together. From #1 to #1, or #1 to #2, or #1 to #3, etc. While
cellulose is a 1-4 linkage, this type of polysaccharide is not digestible
and has no effect in the human body.
Polysaccharides
that are linked with beta bonds at the #1 and #3 position though are
a different story. These are the compounds that stimulate function
and act in conjunction with the human immune system. These 1-3 beta
glucans are mandatory for proper immune system function. They are
available only through dietary sources and are in ever dwindling supply
in our foodstuffs due to our modern farming practices. Chemical fertilizers
interfere with the production of 1-3 beta glucan in plants.
This
is where the different mushroom derived compounds come in. The cell
walls in mushrooms are not like plants. Rather than cellulose as is
found in plants, the mushroom cell walls are composed of 1-3 beta
glucan. Each mushroom has a slightly different structure to their
1-3 beta glucan. For instance, some are attached to a protein, or
have a branching chain structure, or some other structural difference.
Each of these different structures has a slightly different effect
in the body's immune system. Some activate this type of cell or that
type of cell, some differentiate different immune responses, some
are involved in the 'memory' effect of the immune system, etc.
Starting
in the late 60's, there was a lot of research done on the different
sources of mushroom polysaccharides. This resulted in many different
drugs and supplements, such as Lentinan, D-Fraction, AHCC, Arabinoxylane
(MGN-3), PSP and PSK, Coriolan, Sonifilan, Schizophylin and many others.
These all followed the well known theory of modern medicine - "One
Disease, One Molecule". Single medicines extracted and purified
away from all of the other related compounds. Too bad that life is
not so simple as that.
In reality,
when disease occurs, how can we possibly say what aspect of immune
dysfunction allowed it to happen? Is it lowered NK cell activity (take
MGN3 then...) or is it lowered T-cell count (D-fraction!) or perhaps
a lack of the body's normal Tumor Necrosis Factor (PSP! PSK! Coriolan!
etc, etc, etc)
The truth
is, we do not know what causes some people to get sick and others
to remain healthy. The great mystery of life. The human body, the
organism as a whole, functions as a whole. We can't accept that if
you have hepatitis or cancer then this or that is going to help. It
might. But if that is not what your body needs, then it won't.
In the
last ten years there have been some very far reaching advances made
by some very good scientists like Paul Stamets, Malcolm Clark, Andy
Miller and John Saline. They were all on the same track. Combining
Different Beta Glucan Structure to stimulate Different aspects of
the immune system simultaneously. This is why there are so many multi-mushroom
formulas today. RM-10 is an excellent one, as is Stamets 7, Nikken
Immunity, MycoSurge and the many fine products put out by Mushroom
Science and New Chapter. I applaud the developers of these multiple
mushroom formulas. They always work better at addressing disease states
than single mushroom entities.
While
the products I mention here are all available as Health Supplements,
and they all are good choices at maintaining a healthy immune system,
at times there is a need for something stronger. In dealing with serious
disease states such as AIDS, Cancer and Hepatitis, a much more aggressive
approach is needed. I guess one could take a bottle or two of each
of these products a day... That is what it would take to get a sufficient
quantity of 1-3 Beta Glucan in the body to do some good.
The pharmaceutical
companies take a different approach. Patent a Single Compound and
sell it for a lot of money. AHCC, MGN3, LENTINAN and the others I
mention in the title were all developed by pharmaceutical companies
and are used as prescription medicines in most countries. Enough Beta-Glucan
perhaps, just hope it's the one YOU need!
This
is where Immune-Assist is different. What we have done is taken seven
different compounds from 6 different mushrooms (two different compounds
from Cordyceps sinensis) and combined them together into a formulation
which has a higher Beta Glucan content than any of the title compounds.
Immune-Assist actually has all of the named compounds in it. Of course
these names are all trademarked so we can't say that. All of the compounds
in Immune-Assist were originally researched and developed by big pharmaceutical
companies, and are all used as single entity prescription drugs in
other countries. by combining these different structural Beta Glucans,
Immune-Assist has shown a greater effectiveness in all the trials
than Any of the single components.
45% 1-3
Beta Glucan, with over 200 different modes of action identified. That
is why Immune-Assist outperforms MGN3, AHCC, Lentinan, PSK, PSP, Coriolan
and Maitake D-Fraction. As far as comparing Immune-Assist to RM10,
Immunity, Stamets 7, Manipol or any of the other consumer grade polysaccharide
supplements, that is really comparing apples to oranges. The usual
over-the-counter health supplements definitely have a place, but not
as adjunct treatment for serious disease states.
Immune-Assist
is not for everyone. But if you need some Serious Help for Serious
Health Issues, use Immune-Assist.
Note
on "Beta Glucan" in health supplements: There is a type
of 1-3 beta glucan found in yeast. This is the common source of "beta
glucan" that you see in so many health supplements these days.
The yeast beta glucan has very little effect in the human system.
There are NO prescription drugs made anywhere from yeast beta glucans.
(There are over 40 different prescription drugs made from mushrooms).
The claims usually made for the yeast beta glucans is based on research
done with fish in Norway 20 years ago. Works OK for fish. Too bad
it doesn't work for humans. Yeast beta glucan is a marketing scheme
to make a big profit on cheap raw materials produced in China. Don't
waste your money on it. If the label does not say what the source
is, don't buy it. Believe me, when a supplement manufacturer spends
the money to use effective, mushroom derived beta glucans, you can
be sure they will tell you about it.
A
book I recommend for anyone interested in Medicinal Mushrooms is by
Andrew Miller and George Halpern - "Medicinal Mushrooms: Ancient
Remedies for Modern Ailments"
The
Book-Of-All-Books on the subject of Medicinal Mushrooms is by Dr. John
Smith from Scotland..."Medicinal mushrooms: their therapeutic properties
and current medical usage with special emphasis on cancer treatments"
Now there's a book! it can be downloaded in it's entirety here:
http://sci.cancerresearchuk.org/labs/med_mush/med_mush.html
NOTE:
These claims have not been evaluated by the FDA. Our products
are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.
Health decisions are much too important to be made without the
advice of a Doctor or other Health Care Practitoner. We invite
and encourage you to share this information with your doctor.
We are happy to share all of our research materials with any
doctor who asks. |
|